clock menu more-arrow no yes

The Ultimate Guide To Ordering Pie Before Thanksgiving

Here are 15 options for bakeries that make pies in Denver and beyond.

View as Map

Tradition, magic, memories, call it what you want but holidays are not appropriate unless the round crust sandwiched pecan or pumpkin or apple filling makes its way to the table. Pie shops around the metro area are gearing up for Thanksgiving with new flavor combinations, gluten-free options, and more.

Fifteen different shops and bakeries are listed for you to choose from. Weight your options carefully and consider going outside the box with choices like the Helliemae's Chili Palmer Pecan Pie at Wednesday's Pie, the cherry pie at the Post, or the traditional yet unexpected Linzer Torte at City Bakery.

· 18 Great Fall Cocktails to Try Now [EDEN]
· The Cocktail Heatmap: Where to Drink Now [EDEN]
· Denver's Wine Renaissance Starts in Its Newest Bars [EDEN]
· Where to Eat Right Now: The November Heatmap [EDEN]

Read More
Note: Restaurants on this map are listed geographically.

1. Wednesday's Pie

Copy Link
1422 Larimer Street
Denver, CO 80202
(303) 893-6505
Visit Website
There's mint fudge pie, caramel apple pie, and the killer Hellimaes Chili Palmer pecan pie, among others. Prices range between $25 and $30.

2. Walnut Cafe

Copy Link
3073 Walnut St
Boulder, CO 80301
(303) 447-2315
Visit Website
Only 100 pies are made for Thanksgiving and you can order yours now. Whole pies start at $13.50. If you aren't lucky enough to get a Thanksgiving pie, visit the shop on Tuesdays for the best selection of pies available.

3. Lucky's Bakehouse & Creamery

Copy Link
(720) 596-4905
Visit Website
For Thanksgiving, the Bakehouse is making Mile High apple pie, salted maple chocolate chunk pecan pie, and a ginger snap pumpkin pie, also available gluten free. Naturally gluten free is the flourless spiced chocolate cake.

4. Devil's Food

Copy Link
1020 S Gaylord St
Denver, CO 80209
(303) 733-7448
Visit Website
Three classics-- pecan, apple and pumpkin (with house-roasted pumpkin purée) -- are available for $20 each. A French Chocolate Tart as well as a Chestnut Cheesecake are also being offered.

5. Cake Crumbs

Copy Link
2216 Kearney St
Denver, CO 80207
(303) 861-4912
Visit Website
Nine inch pies in five flavors- pumpkin, pecan, chocolate pecan, apple and coconut cream are available for ordering now until November 24 with the 27 being the last pick up day. The pies cost between $18 and $21 with a gluten free option for pumpkin and pecan that costs $25 and $28 respectively.

6. City Bakery Cafe

Copy Link
726 Lincoln Street
Denver, CO 80203
(303) 292-3989
Visit Website
Pumpkin Spice Tart and Pecan Hazelnut Tart are available to order for the holidays. They cost $24 and $30 respectively and come with a spiced Anglaise sauce. For a nontraditional option, consider the irresistible Linzer Torte.

7. Edge Restaurant

Copy Link
1111 14th St
Denver, CO 80202
There are three flavors available for ordering: black-bottom pecan, classic pumpkin, or apple streusel. All pies are made with a house made 9" pie shell, serve 10 to 12 people and retail for $25.

8. Granny Scott's Pie Shop

Copy Link
3333 S Wadsworth Blvd
Lakewood, CO 80227
(303) 986-6240
Visit Website
In addition to its selection of regular pies, this holiday, the shop will make mince meat pie, sugar-free pumpkin, sweet potato pie, and brandy nut pie. Gluten-free pies are available.

9. Leaf & Crumb

Copy Link
4416 E 8th Ave
Denver, CO 80220
(303) 355-0022
Visit Website
The pastry shop is featuring pumpkin, cinnamon- apple, pecan, chocolate cream, and berry-hibiscus. Orders can be placed by calling or online.

10. My Mom's Pie

Copy Link
201 Murray St Unit C
Niwot, CO 80544
(303) 652-6667
Visit Website
Traditional holiday pies, fruit pies, and chocolate cream pies, this shop does it all. They deliver in Boulder County for $5, ship via FedEx in the United States, and will consider making a custom pie if you request one.

11. Sugarmill

Copy Link
2461 Larimer Street
Denver, CO 80205
(303) 297-3540
Visit Website
The TAG Restaurant Group is offering four kinds of pies crafted by the pastry chefs at Sugarmill: apple crumble, pecan, pumpkin, and bourbon pecan chocolate chip ranging in price between $23 and $28. Orders can be placed by calling 303.297.3540.

12. The Huckleberry

Copy Link
700 Main St
Louisville, CO 80027
(303) 666-8020
Visit Website
Pie selections can include peach huckleberry, blackberry, apple crumble, chocolate bourbon pecan, cherry, and more. Call the restaurant and pie shop for available selection and more information.

13. The Post Brewing Company

Copy Link
105 W Emma St
Lafayette, CO 80026
(303) 593-2066
Visit Website
The Post is taking phone-in orders (303.593.2066) for its cherry, pumpkin, and pecan pies, to be picked up on Wednesday, November 26. The prices range between $19.95 and $24.95.

14. Adagio Bakery & Cafe

Copy Link
217 S Holly St
Denver, CO
Four classic pies are offered before Thanksgiving: apple, cherry, pumpkin, and pecan. During the rest of the year, the bakery offers a wider selection.

15. The Long I Pie

Copy Link
2500 Larimer Street
Denver, CO 80205
This mobile pie shop makes its creations in cast iron pans. For the holiday, three sweet pies are offered: bourbon chocolate pecan, pear and lavender, and salted lavender honey custard. For truck stops and ordering info, visit the website.

Loading comments...

1. Wednesday's Pie

1422 Larimer Street, Denver, CO 80202
There's mint fudge pie, caramel apple pie, and the killer Hellimaes Chili Palmer pecan pie, among others. Prices range between $25 and $30.
1422 Larimer Street
Denver, CO 80202

2. Walnut Cafe

3073 Walnut St, Boulder, CO 80301
Only 100 pies are made for Thanksgiving and you can order yours now. Whole pies start at $13.50. If you aren't lucky enough to get a Thanksgiving pie, visit the shop on Tuesdays for the best selection of pies available.
3073 Walnut St
Boulder, CO 80301

3. Lucky's Bakehouse & Creamery

Boulder, CO 80304
For Thanksgiving, the Bakehouse is making Mile High apple pie, salted maple chocolate chunk pecan pie, and a ginger snap pumpkin pie, also available gluten free. Naturally gluten free is the flourless spiced chocolate cake.

4. Devil's Food

1020 S Gaylord St, Denver, CO 80209
Three classics-- pecan, apple and pumpkin (with house-roasted pumpkin purée) -- are available for $20 each. A French Chocolate Tart as well as a Chestnut Cheesecake are also being offered.
1020 S Gaylord St
Denver, CO 80209

5. Cake Crumbs

2216 Kearney St, Denver, CO 80207
Nine inch pies in five flavors- pumpkin, pecan, chocolate pecan, apple and coconut cream are available for ordering now until November 24 with the 27 being the last pick up day. The pies cost between $18 and $21 with a gluten free option for pumpkin and pecan that costs $25 and $28 respectively.
2216 Kearney St
Denver, CO 80207

6. City Bakery Cafe

726 Lincoln Street, Denver, CO 80203
Pumpkin Spice Tart and Pecan Hazelnut Tart are available to order for the holidays. They cost $24 and $30 respectively and come with a spiced Anglaise sauce. For a nontraditional option, consider the irresistible Linzer Torte.
726 Lincoln Street
Denver, CO 80203

7. Edge Restaurant

1111 14th St, Denver, CO 80202
There are three flavors available for ordering: black-bottom pecan, classic pumpkin, or apple streusel. All pies are made with a house made 9" pie shell, serve 10 to 12 people and retail for $25.
1111 14th St
Denver, CO 80202

8. Granny Scott's Pie Shop

3333 S Wadsworth Blvd, Lakewood, CO 80227
In addition to its selection of regular pies, this holiday, the shop will make mince meat pie, sugar-free pumpkin, sweet potato pie, and brandy nut pie. Gluten-free pies are available.
3333 S Wadsworth Blvd
Lakewood, CO 80227

9. Leaf & Crumb

4416 E 8th Ave, Denver, CO 80220
The pastry shop is featuring pumpkin, cinnamon- apple, pecan, chocolate cream, and berry-hibiscus. Orders can be placed by calling or online.
4416 E 8th Ave
Denver, CO 80220

10. My Mom's Pie

201 Murray St Unit C, Niwot, CO 80544
Traditional holiday pies, fruit pies, and chocolate cream pies, this shop does it all. They deliver in Boulder County for $5, ship via FedEx in the United States, and will consider making a custom pie if you request one.
201 Murray St Unit C
Niwot, CO 80544

11. Sugarmill

2461 Larimer Street, Denver, CO 80205
The TAG Restaurant Group is offering four kinds of pies crafted by the pastry chefs at Sugarmill: apple crumble, pecan, pumpkin, and bourbon pecan chocolate chip ranging in price between $23 and $28. Orders can be placed by calling 303.297.3540.
2461 Larimer Street
Denver, CO 80205

12. The Huckleberry

700 Main St, Louisville, CO 80027
Pie selections can include peach huckleberry, blackberry, apple crumble, chocolate bourbon pecan, cherry, and more. Call the restaurant and pie shop for available selection and more information.
700 Main St
Louisville, CO 80027

13. The Post Brewing Company

105 W Emma St, Lafayette, CO 80026
The Post is taking phone-in orders (303.593.2066) for its cherry, pumpkin, and pecan pies, to be picked up on Wednesday, November 26. The prices range between $19.95 and $24.95.
105 W Emma St
Lafayette, CO 80026

14. Adagio Bakery & Cafe

217 S Holly St, Denver, CO
Four classic pies are offered before Thanksgiving: apple, cherry, pumpkin, and pecan. During the rest of the year, the bakery offers a wider selection.
217 S Holly St
Denver, CO

15. The Long I Pie

2500 Larimer Street, Denver, CO 80205
This mobile pie shop makes its creations in cast iron pans. For the holiday, three sweet pies are offered: bourbon chocolate pecan, pear and lavender, and salted lavender honey custard. For truck stops and ordering info, visit the website.
2500 Larimer Street
Denver, CO 80205

Related Maps